Anytime Fitness vs Planet Fitness: Which Gym Membership Is Right for You?

Choosing a gym can feel overwhelming, but it often comes down to your budget, workout style, and schedule. Planet Fitness stands out for its budget-friendly, beginner-welcoming vibe with the “Judgment Free Zone,” making it great for casual fitness fans. 

Anytime Fitness, on the other hand, offers round-the-clock access and more robust equipment, appealing to those who want flexibility and serious training options. 

Key factors to weigh include costs, equipment variety, hours, and extras like classes or training. Let’s explore how they compare to help you pick the best fit.

Planet Fitness vs Anytime Fitness Side-by-Side Comparison

For a quick glance, here’s how these gyms match up on core features. Keep in mind, details can vary by location, always check your local spot.

Feature	Planet Fitness	Anytime Fitness
Monthly Cost	Classic: $10–$15; Black Card: $23–$25 (plus taxes; varies by area)	$40–$60 (billed monthly or bi-weekly; includes possible initiation fee of $50–$100)
24/7 Access	Many locations are 24/7, though some close weekends or holidays	Yes, all gyms open 24/7 with secure key fob or app entry
Free Weights	Basic setup: Dumbbells up to 75–80 lbs, focus on machines over heavy lifts	Full range: Heavy dumbbells, barbells, squat racks, and powerlifting gear
Atmosphere	Relaxed and non-intimidating with the “lunk alarm”; can get busy	Supportive community feel; often less crowded, ideal for focused workouts
Personal Training	Available for an extra fee; geared toward basics and beginners	Customized sessions with nutrition and recovery advice, plus app support
Classes	Limited to circuit training and some group options; Black Card adds massage chair perks	App-based with 3 months free Apple Fitness+; includes HIIT, yoga, and more

Detailed Breakdown

Membership Costs

Planet Fitness

• Their plans keep things simple and affordable. The Classic membership runs about $10–$15 per month, giving you access to one home club with essentials like cardio machines and Wi-Fi.
• Upgrade to the Black Card for $23–$25 monthly, which unlocks all 2,500+ locations, guest passes, and bonuses like tanning or HydroMassage.
• Don’t forget the annual fee—around $49, usually billed in summer.
• Promotions like $1 down can sweeten the deal, but prices shift by location.

Anytime Fitness

• Expect to pay $40–$60 per month, depending on your area and plan—some bill bi-weekly for $25–$35.
• There’s often an enrollment fee of $50–$100 to start.
• All memberships include global access to over 5,000 locations after 30 days, plus app perks.
• No strict tiers, but you can add family options or short-term deals.
• After the free 3-month Apple Fitness+ trial, it’s an extra $9.99 monthly if you keep it.
• Franchises set their own rates, so shop around.

Best For

Choose Planet Fitness If:

• Budget is key, and you like a welcoming spot for light workouts or cardio without pressure.
• You’re starting fresh and appreciate the no-judgment policy to feel comfortable.
• Extras like bringing a buddy or using perks at various locations appeal, especially for occasional travel.
• Crowds don’t faze you, and you want widespread access on the cheap.
• User feedback often notes its cleanliness and ease for newcomers, though it can feel packed.

Choose Anytime Fitness If:

• You value heavy-duty gear and true 24/7 flexibility for strength training anytime.
• Personalized coaching and tech tools, like progress tracking in the app, help you stay committed.
• Frequent trips mean you need reliable global access without limits.
• A quieter, community-driven space suits your routine better.
• Reviews highlight the quality equipment and support, but mention the higher price as a downside for some.

Hidden Fees & Policies of Both Gyms

Gym contracts can surprise you with extras, so review yours closely. Policies differ by location and state.

Fees Comparison

Fee Type	Planet Fitness	Anytime Fitness
Annual Fee	$49, billed yearly (e.g., June); cancel by 25th of prior month to avoid.	None standard, but some franchises add maintenance fees—confirm locally.
Cancellation Fee	$58 buyout for early termination in 12-month plans; in-person or mail only, before 10th of month.	$50 or more if ending early; 30-day notice, via email/form or in-person.
Freeze Policy	Possible for medical reasons or moves; $5–$10/month, sometimes free for Black Card.	Up to 3 months, twice yearly; no standard fee, but check your contract.
Other Hidden Fees	Late payments; no partial refunds; charges if not canceled properly.	Potential early termination penalties or auto-renew add-ons like Apple Fitness.

FAQs

Which gym has better strength equipment?

Anytime Fitness takes the lead with comprehensive free weights, racks, and heavy-lifting options, while Planet Fitness prioritizes machines and lighter weights for a beginner-friendly setup.setforset.commyfliip.com

Can I use any location with my membership?

For Planet Fitness, Black Card members can visit all 2,500+ spots; Classic sticks to your home club. Anytime Fitness lets you access any of their 5,000+ worldwide after 30 days.anytimefitness.com

Are there free trials?

Planet Fitness runs promotions like day passes or $1 down deals, but no standard trial. Anytime Fitness often offers a 7-day free passask at your local gym.anytimefitness.com

To round things out, consider your routine: If crowds bother you, Anytime’s smaller vibe might win; for value, Planet’s hard to beat. What’s your main goal—saving cash or building muscle? I could suggest ways to test both, like using guest passes, or compare with other chains if needed.