When it comes to gym philosophies, Planet Fitness promotes a “Judgment Free Zone” focused on accessibility and comfort for everyday folks, keeping things affordable and low-pressure. 24 Hour Fitness emphasizes round-the-clock convenience with a more traditional setup, catering to varied fitness levels through premium amenities and classes. Key decision factors include budget, equipment needs, hours, and atmosphere—PF wins on cost for beginners, while 24HF edges out for serious training with better gear.
Planet Fitness vs 24 Hour Fitness Side-by-Side Comparison
Here’s how they compare, with winners noted where clear. Details vary by location, so verify locally. 24HF often takes the lead on equipment and classes, but PF dominates affordability.
| Feature | Planet Fitness (Winner: Budget) | 24 Hour Fitness (Winner: Equipment/Classes) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | Classic: $10–$15; Black Card: $23–$25 | Silver/Gold/Platinum: $30–$60+ (varies by tier/location) |
| 24/7 Access | Many locations, but some limited | Yes, true 24/7 at most clubs |
| Free Weights | Limited; dumbbells up to 75–80 lbs | Extensive; heavy dumbbells, barbells, squat racks |
| Atmosphere | Relaxed, beginner-friendly with “lunk alarm” | Energetic, traditional gym vibe; can be crowded |
| Classes | Limited circuit training; app-based options | GX24® studio/cycle classes in Gold/Platinum |
| Personal Training | Available for extra fee; basic sessions | Included free session in Platinum; advanced options |
Detailed Breakdown
Membership Cost
Planet Fitness:
Classic starts at $10–$15 monthly for home club access with basics like cardio and Wi-Fi. Black Card ($23–$25) adds multi-location entry, guests, and perks like massage chairs. Expect a $49 annual fee billed mid-year, plus possible $1–$49 startup.
24 Hour Fitness:
Silver offers single-club access from $30+, Gold adds regional perks and classes around $40–$50, Platinum provides national entry and full amenities at $50–$60+. Initiation fees vary ($0–$99), with a $59.99 annual fee. Friends/family add-ons waive some costs.
Best For
Choose Planet Fitness If:
You’re after the lowest price and a non-intimidating environment for cardio or basic machines. It’s perfect for beginners who want a chill space without heavy lifters around. The focus on comfort helps ease into fitness routines.
Choose 24 Hour Fitness If:
You need true 24/7 access, heavy free weights, squat racks, or group classes/personal training. It suits those progressing beyond basics with more dynamic options. The variety supports long-term goals like strength building.
Hidden Fees & Policies
Contracts can hide surprises, so read carefully. Policies update yearly and vary by state.
| Fee Type | Planet Fitness | 24 Hour Fitness |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Fee | $49, billed mid-year (cancel by 25th prior month) | $59.99, billed on 15th after join |
| Cancellation Fee | $58 buyout if in commitment; in-person/mail only | Varies; online/phone/in-person, process within 10 days |
| Freeze Policy | Medical/relo; $5–$10/month or free for Black Card | Allowed if in good standing; fee may apply, counts toward commitment |
FAQs
Which gym is better for beginners?
Planet Fitness, with its welcoming vibe and lighter equipment to build confidence without intimidation.
Does 24 Hour Fitness have better equipment than Planet Fitness?
Yes, especially for strength training with squat racks and heavier weights, versus PF’s machine-focused setup.
Can I cancel online?
PF requires in-person or mail; 24HF allows online, phone, or in-person as of 2025 updates.
Bronson Vaughan is a fitness enthusiast dedicated to helping others achieve their health goals. With a passion for active living, he shares expert advice and practical tips on finding the best fitness programs and memberships for individuals and families.