Considering Planet Fitness and Orangetheory suggests you’re debating between a standard gym and structured group sessions.
Planet Fitness offers a relaxed entry with its Judgment Free Zone, perfect for self-paced exploration. Orangetheory uses heart rate tech for intense, science-backed HIIT classes, fostering community and results.
Evaluate cost, format, intensity, and setting, where Planet Fitness is budget king for flexibility and Orangetheory excels in guided motivation.
Plaent Fitness vs Orangetheory Side-by-Side Comparison
View the contrasts, with winners noted. Plans differ by studio, so check. Orangetheory leads in structured workouts, Planet Fitness in low stakes.
| Feature | Planet Fitness (Winner: Monthly Cost) |
Orangetheory (Winner: Classes) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | Classic: $15; Black Card: $24.99 | Basic: $59; Unlimited: $169+ |
| Free Weights | Limited; up to 75–80 lbs dumbbells | Functional; used in classes |
| Cardio Machines | Treadmills, ellipticals, bikes | Rowers, treads in sessions |
| Classes | Limited circuit; app-based | HIIT with heart monitoring |
| Atmosphere | Casual, independent | Intense, group-driven |
| 24/7 Access | Yes often | Scheduled classes only |
Detailed Breakdown
Membership Cost
Planet Fitness:
Classic $15 for free use of equipment. Black Card $24.99 for perks. Annual $49, easy signups.
Orangetheory:
Basic $59 for 4 classes/month. Unlimited $169 for endless access. No annual, but freeze fees possible.
Best For
Choose Planet Fitness If:
You favor low cost for self-guided cardio or weights in a chill space. It’s for those easing in. The freedom allows personal pace.
Choose Orangetheory If:
You thrive on classes, tech tracking, and high energy. It’s for goal-oriented folks. The format drives results through accountability.
Hidden Fees & Policies
Note potential extras in signup. Policies adapt by site.
| Fee Type | Planet Fitness | Orangetheory |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Fee | $49, yearly | None; session-based |
| Cancellation Fee | $58 early | 30-day notice; no major |
| Freeze Policy | Monthly charge | Free short freezes |
FAQs
Is Orangetheory worth the cost?
Yes for class lovers; results from structure justify it.
Can beginners do Orangetheory?
Yes, scalable intensities. Coaches adjust.
Does Orangetheory have free trials?
Yes, first class free. Test the format.
How does Orangetheory differ from Planet Fitness?
OTF is class-only, PF is open gym.
Bronson Vaughan is a fitness enthusiast dedicated to helping others achieve their health goals. With a passion for active living, he shares expert advice and practical tips on finding the best fitness programs and memberships for individuals and families.